roombatch

Moulding & trimCompare styles

Wainscoting vs Board and Batten vs Shiplap: Which to Choose

These three words get used interchangeably, but they describe different things. Wainscoting is where the panelling goes, board and batten is one way to build it, and shiplap is a board with a particular edge. Here is how to tell them apart, which suits which room, and what each takes to build on the same 12 ft wall.

7 min readPublished By the RoomBatch editorial team
On this page
  1. Key takeaways
  2. Sorting out the words
  3. How each one looks
  4. Same wall, three builds
  5. Skill, time and tools
  6. Matching style to room
  7. Mixing styles without a muddle
  8. Practicalities: outlets, fixing and finish
  9. Questions

Key takeaways

  • Wainscoting is any panelling on the lower part of a wall; board and batten, picture frame and beadboard are all ways to do it.
  • Board and batten is the easiest paint-grade option: flat strips, butt joints, simple math.
  • Shiplap covers the whole surface in overlapping boards, so it uses far more material and hides wall flaws.
  • Picture frame moulding is the most formal and the most cutting: eight mitres per box.
  • On a 12 ft wall at about 36 in high, expect roughly 8 to 13 eight-foot boards depending on the style.

Sorting out the words

Wainscoting describes position, not construction. Traditionally it is panelling on the lower part of a wall, roughly 3 to 4 ft high, often capped with a rail. Raised panels, flat recessed panels, beadboard, board and batten and picture frame moulding can all be wainscoting when they stop partway up the wall.

Board and batten describes construction: flat boards (or a flat wall) with narrower battens applied over them at even spacing. It can be wainscot height or run to the ceiling.

Shiplap describes a board. Each board has a rabbet along its edges so neighbours overlap, leaving a small shadow gap. Indoors it is usually run horizontally across a whole wall, though vertical shiplap and wainscot-height shiplap are both common now.

How each one looks

Board and batten reads as a rhythm of vertical lines and recessed bays. It is clean, a little farmhouse or Craftsman at low heights, and crisp and modern at full height in a dark color.

Picture frame moulding reads as formal and classical: rectangles of thin profiled trim, often with a chair rail. It suits dining rooms, hallways and older houses.

Shiplap reads as texture: long horizontal shadow lines that widen a room. It can feel coastal or rustic in white, and surprisingly modern in a deep color or run vertically.

Beadboard, a cousin worth knowing, is narrow vertical grooves, often sold as 4 by 8 ft sheets. It is cottage-style and very quick to install.

How each one looks
StyleFeelsCovers the wall?Hides flaws?
Board and battenClean, rhythmicNo, bays show the wallPartly
Picture frame mouldingFormal, classicalNoLeast
ShiplapTextured, relaxedYes, edge to edgeMost
BeadboardCottage, cosyYesMostly

Same wall, three builds

Compare them on one 12 ft (144 in) wall, all at about 36 to 40 in high, using 8 ft stock and a 10% allowance.

Board and batten at 40 in with 2.5 in boards at a 16 in target: 10 verticals at 15.72 in centres, each 35 in long, plus top and bottom rails. Two verticals fit per board, so RoomBatch packs it into 8 boards, 9 with allowance.

Picture frame moulding below a chair rail: with a 96 in wall height, RoomBatch puts the rail at 32 in. Three boxes 42.67 in wide by 24 in tall (4 in margins and gaps), plus a 144 in chair rail, is about 45 linear ft. That is a modest stick count, but 24 mitre cuts.

Horizontal shiplap to 36 in with boards showing about 5 1/8 in each: 7 rows. Each 144 in row needs one 8 ft board plus a 4 ft piece, and two 4 ft pieces come from one board, so 11 boards, 13 with allowance, plus a cap.

Same wall, three builds
Build (12 ft wall)PiecesCuts8 ft boards (with 10%)
Board and batten, 40 in10 verticals + 2 railsSquare cuts only9
Picture frame, 3 boxes + chair rail12 sides + rail24 mitresabout 7
Shiplap, 36 in, 7 rows7 rows of 2 piecesSquare cuts + rip top row13

Skill, time and tools

Board and batten is the friendliest first project. Every cut is square, the joints are butts, and filler and caulk hide small errors. A miter saw (or even a hand saw and guide), a brad nailer, a level and a caulk gun cover it.

Picture frame moulding asks for accurate 45 degree cuts and matching lengths. It is not hard, but it is unforgiving: a box that is 1/16 in out of square shows. A good miter saw and a stop block are essential.

Shiplap is mostly repetition, but the first row must be dead level, rows must be ripped to fit at the top, and boards must be nailed into studs. A table saw or track saw for ripping the last row helps a lot.

  • Fastest: beadboard sheets, then board and batten
  • Most cuts per square foot: picture frame moulding
  • Most material per square foot: shiplap
  • Most forgiving of a bumpy wall: shiplap and beadboard

Matching style to room

Bathrooms and laundry rooms favour PVC board and batten or PVC beadboard, because both resist splashes. Dining rooms and formal hallways suit picture frame moulding with a chair rail at about a third of the wall. Bedrooms suit tall board and batten or a full-height grid behind the bed. Living rooms with a bumpy or patched wall benefit from shiplap, which covers everything.

Think about the furniture too. Picture frame boxes partly hidden by a sofa look awkward. Board and batten and shiplap do not mind being partly covered, because they read as a pattern rather than as individual frames.

Mixing styles without a muddle

You can combine these, and some combinations are classics: beadboard below a chair rail with plain paint above, or board and batten at 60 in with a picture ledge on top. The rule is one dominant pattern per wall. Shiplap below and picture frame boxes above, on the same wall, gives the eye two competing rhythms and usually looks like two projects that met by accident.

If neighbouring walls get different treatments, keep a shared line. Run the top of the wainscot on one wall at the same height as the chair rail on the next, and keep the trim color consistent. A continuous horizontal line around a room ties different styles together far better than matching materials do.

Practicalities: outlets, fixing and finish

Coverage styles change the wall plane. Shiplap or beadboard over drywall moves the surface out by the board thickness, so outlets and switches inside the panelled area usually need box extenders to bring devices flush with the new face. Board and batten and picture frame moulding leave the wall surface inside the bays untouched, so outlets there need nothing new. Turn the breaker off before removing any cover plate, and call an electrician if you are unsure.

All four install with construction adhesive and brad or finish nails, driven into studs at 16 in centres where possible. Scan for pipes and cables before nailing and ventilate while adhesive cures. Finish with filler in nail holes, caulk where trim meets wall, primer on cut MDF edges, and a satin or semi-gloss enamel.

Questions people ask

Is board and batten the same as wainscoting?

Board and batten can be a type of wainscoting when it covers the lower part of a wall. Wainscoting is the broader term for any lower-wall panelling, including beadboard, raised panels and picture frame moulding.

Which is cheaper, shiplap or board and batten?

Board and batten usually needs less material because the bays show the wall. On a 12 ft wall at about 36 to 40 in, board and batten might need 9 boards against about 13 for shiplap, at similar per-board prices.

Does shiplap go horizontal or vertical?

Either. Horizontal shiplap widens a room and is the classic look. Vertical shiplap makes ceilings feel taller and reads more modern. The planning math is the same, just turned 90 degrees.

What is the easiest wall panelling for beginners?

Board and batten or beadboard sheets. Both use square cuts and forgiving butt joints. Picture frame moulding requires accurate mitres; shiplap requires level rows and ripping.

How high should wainscoting be?

Traditionally about 3 to 4 ft, or about a third of the wall height. Taller treatments around 60 in or two thirds are popular now. Avoid exactly halfway up the wall.

Sources & further reading

  1. Panelling and wainscot (Wikipedia) (opens in a new tab)
  2. Shiplap: rabbeted board profile (Wikipedia) (opens in a new tab)

Planning information only. Product labels, manufacturer instructions and local codes take priority. Prices are illustrative. Read how we write and check guides in our editorial policy.

Was this guide useful?